Am I alone in thinking that the ConDem education policies are fundamentally schizophrenic?
This week we have the release of the new school league tables for England. These include the results and league rankings for the new English Baccalaureate which was only announced weeks ago. So schools are already being rated on a new system which they have not been given any opportunity to prepare for. And what is this English Baccalaureate anyway? Well, its a set of different subjects – English, Math, one science, one modern language and either history or geography. If a student passes these five subjects, they have achieved the English Baccalaureate.
Many head teachers are unhappy that the results of this arbitrary new qualification are already in the league table:
ASCL’s Brian Lightman said: “We are in favour of a broad curriculum and for as many pupils as possible to get into the best universities – but education is not just about university entrance.
“This will devalue vocational education and marginalise it.”
The selection of courses that count as a humanity for the Baccalaureate is very arbitrary – Religious Education, Music or Art don’t count. A very academic (non-vocational, non-creative) model is now being pushed for schools while at the same time David Willetts, Gove’s Conservative cabinet colleague, is promoting vocational education as an alternative to academic education for school leavers and considers that too many children may be going to university (e.g. here and here).
That there is no need for, and that government should not support, lots of (unneeded) humanities graduates is a recurring theme of commentators in the Telegraph – so why is history being given more importance as a school subject than art, at a time when creative arts (including animation) are a cornerstone of modern commerce and industry?
I watched this Ken Robinson video again on YouTube. I wish Michael Gove would watch it and pay attention. But given Gove’s brush off of similar complaints that his Baccalaureate undervalues creativity and art, I doubt it would have any effect.
